Brazil has been the world leader in promoting biofuels
for 25 years under its "ProAlcool" program. Policies have
included blending mandates, retail distribution requirements,
production subsidies, and other measures. Since
1975, Brazil has mandated that ethanol be blended with
all gasoline sold. Although the required blend level is
adjusted frequently, it has been in the range of 20–25 percent.
All gas stations are required to sell gasohol (E25) and
pure ethanol (E100). Tax preferences have been given to
vehicles that run on pure ethanol. The recent introduction
and soaring sales of so-called "flex-fuel" vehicles by several
automakers was not driven primarily by policy, but the
government did extend the preferential vehicle licensing
tax to cover flexible-fuel cars, beyond the original coverage
of pure ethanol cars.
*1 Brazil has more recently begun to
target increased use of biodiesel fuels, derived primarily
from domestically produced soybean oil. A recent law in
Brazil allows blending of 2-percent biodiesel in diesel fuels
since January 2005. This percentage may be increased to 5
percent or more by 2013.[
N33]
In addition to Brazil, mandates for blending biofuels
into vehicle fuels have been appearing in several other countries
in recent years. In particular, at least 20 states/provinces
and two countries now have mandates for blending ethanol
and/or biodiesel with all vehicle fuels sold. In India, the government
mandated 10-percent ethanol blending (E10) in 9
out of 28 states and 4 out 7 federal territories (all sugar cane
producing areas), starting in 2003. In China, four provinces
mandate E10 blending, and five additional provinces were
slated for a similar mandate in 2005.
*2 In the United States,
three states also mandate E10 blending: Hawaii (most gasoline
by 2006),Minnesota (increasing to 20 percent by 2013),
and Montana.Minnesota also mandates 2-percent blending
of biodiesel (B2), a policy that other states and countries are
considering. In Canada, the province of Ontario mandates
E5 (average) blending by 2007. National blending mandates
have appeared in Columbia (E10) and the Dominican
Republic (E15 and B2 by 2015). Thailand has a target for
biofuels as a share of total energy by 2011, for which it is
considering E10 and B2 blending mandates. Japan is considering
an E5 blending mandate based on imports from
Brazil.[
N33]
Tax incentives for biofuels are most prominent in the
United States, where a number of policies have been
enacted at the state and federal levels over the past 25 years.
The Energy Security Act of 1979 created a federal ethanol
tax credit of up to 60 cents per gallon, proportional to the
blend percentage of the fuel (e.g., 6 cents/gallon for E10).
In 2004, this tax credit was extended through 2010. A tax
credit for biodiesel was also added, of about 1 cent per percentage
point of biodiesel blended (i.e., 2 cents per gallon
for B2). Several U.S. states also offer tax and other incentives
for ethanol production and sales. Canada provides a
national fuel tax exemption of 10 cents per liter, and many
provinces offer similar or higher exemptions (up to 25
cents/liter). A number of European countries provide fuel
or VAT tax exemptions for biofuels, including Austria
(95 percent exemption for biodiesel), France, Germany
(100 percent exemption for biodiesel), Hungary, Italy
(100 percent exemption for biodiesel), Spain, Sweden, and
the United Kingdom.
Several other European countries have been considering
biofuels policies as part of efforts to achieve the EU biofuels
target of 5.75 percent of transport fuels by 2010. An EC
Directive in 2003 provided targets for each country to meet
by 2005 (2 percent) and 2010 (5.75 percent). Although the
targets are voluntary, countries have had to submit plans for
meeting targets, or justifications for why they won’t. Some
EU members have recently enacted biofuels promotion laws
or binding targets, including Hungary, which mandates 2
percent of total energy from biofuels by 2010, and the
Netherlands, with a target of 2 percent of transport fuels.
Footnotes
*1 This turning point, in which half of all new cars sales by 2005 were flex-fuel vehicles, was driven by the voluntary initiative of national automotive manufacturers,
lead by Volkswagen. Producing flex-fuel cars rather than separate pure-ethanol and gasohol models has allowed automakers to simplify supply and
assembly chains.
*2 Due to poor cane crop yields during 2003–2004, India had to import ethanol in order to meet state blending targets, and has had to postpone broader targets
until sufficient supplies of domestic ethanol reappear on the market. Chinese provinces have also had to suspend blending mandates due to ethanol shortages.